Report • Board Game Arena

All reports

lewisclark_displayed reports

#8450: "Discarded goods without overflowing boats"

fixed: Bug has been fixed

What is this report about?

lewisclark #34411028

What happened ? Please select from below

Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected

What happened ? Please select from below

Rules: a rule of the game has not been respected

Please check if there is already a report on the same subject

If yes, please VOTE for this report. Reports with the most votes are taken care of in PRIORITY!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Detailed description

Report history

21. Oct 2017 09:01 • Dashiva • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

I was trying different moves, including one that produced 4 food. This triggered overflow, so I could choose to move some wood out of the boats and food inside them. Then I cancelled this action, and started over, but one wood was left outside the boats. When I confirmed the Pierre-Antoine Tabeau action, this wood did not go inside the boats again, but was actually discarded.

9. Jan 2018 15:49 • ufm • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

This bug occured during my game too. Table #36569798, Move 98.

21. Mar 2019 16:39 • LordChambers • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

I just wanted to bump this issue. Collecting enough goods to overflow the boat capacity makes all the goods on the boat clickable (haloed in blue). This is intended to allow the player to remove them from from the boat, and thereby add to the boat some of the excess resources he or she is collecting that turn. However, once triggered, it allows the player to remove unwanted goods without replacing them. In a game I had 10 goods and 11 total capacity. I played a blacksmith and "collected" 2 equipment but did not put them on my boats. I also threw a good away, ending my turn with 9/11 and no equipment. The rules disallow this. From the FAQ:

Can I “toss my resources overboard”?
No, I am not allowed to get rid of my resources except if, when collecting resources, all my boats, included those I have bought during the game, are full. In this case, I can discard them (put the resources back in the stock) in order to make room to the new resources I have just collected. _The number of old resources I discard in this case equals the number of new resources I collect, so that, at the end of the Collecting action, all my boats are still full_.

24. Mar 2019 00:34 • LordChambers • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

I just realized that a player doesn't even need to overflow total capacity to make all his goods clickable (haloed in blue) and thus discardable.

Step 0: initial situation with unwanted furs (i.imgur.com/PBRn6Rl.png)
Step 1: harvest meat; original cargo is still on the boat (i.imgur.com/uHvm1z3.png)
Step 2: click one of the new meat; original cargo is now clickable (i.imgur.com/yG8SqV6.png)
Step 3: click that cargo right off the boat; you've now ditched unwanted cargo despite it being against the rules (i.imgur.com/l9gnjbe.png))

31. Mar 2019 13:18 • Scouby38 • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

Same issue on Table #49739394, Coup #155, user star (Green) played leather gathering with his boats almost full, gathered 6 leathers then discarded down to three resources.

18. May 2019 23:12 • LordChambers • Bug has not been reproduced by delopers yet:

I messaged with Victoria_La, the developer, and she indicates fixing this problem would require too fundamental of a rework for how the game is programmed, so it will not be fixed.

17. Nov 2019 02:11 • Victoria_La • Bug has been fixed:

Fixed in version 191117-0307

Add something to this report

Please add here anything that seems relevant to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:

Another table ID / move ID
Did F5 solve the problem?
Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.

LB_CANCEL Update report

#8450: "Discarded goods without overflowing boats"

What is this report about?

What happened ? Please select from below

What happened ? Please select from below

Please check if there is already a report on the same subject

Detailed description

Report history

Add something to this report

Change report status to:

LB_HELP

Contribute

Navigate

Follow us